Harlan Coben’s Lazarus disappoints: tangled timelines and flaky narrators turn it into a slog

Show summary Hide summary

Harlan Coben returns to the screen with a moody, London-set thriller that mixes family secrets and possible supernatural visions. The new series trades Coben’s familiar novel adaptations for an original mystery that asks whether trauma can breed madness — or if something darker is at work.

What Harlan Coben’s Lazarus is and where to watch it

Harlan Coben’s Lazarus is a six-episode original mystery created for Prime Video. The show was co-created and executive produced by Coben and Danny Brocklehurst. It marks a departure from Coben’s adaptations and places a fresh story in a modern British setting.

Central premise: a son returns to an unsettling past

The narrative follows Joel Lazarus, a troubled psychologist who left London years earlier. The death of his father drags him back into a life he tried to escape. Joel confronts the unresolved murder of his twin sister and a string of odd occurrences linked to his late father’s practice.

  • Joel Lazarus (played by Sam Claflin) is haunted by his sister’s unsolved death.
  • Dr. Jonathan Lazarus (Bill Nighy) ran a prestigious therapy practice with secrets in its files.
  • Joel begins to experience visions of dead former clients who seem to be trying to tell him something.

How the mystery unfolds across episodes

The plot moves like an investigative journal. Joel assembles clues on a murder board. Old case files, unexpected corpses, and resurfacing suspects push him deeper into obsession. The show layers procedural beats over personal trauma.

Key plot mechanics

  • Supernatural-tinged visions act as catalysts for each new revelation.
  • Family dynamics complicate the investigation, from estranged siblings to ex-lovers.
  • Legacy and reputation shape how characters react to accusations and secrets.

Visual style and storytelling choices

The series leans heavily into mood. Cinematography and sound design are used to evoke claustrophobia and unease. At times this approach sharpens the mystery. Other times it feels overwrought.

Frequent flashbacks and memory sequences aim to blur reality and grief. The score, often ominous and choir-driven, pushes scenes toward melodrama. These choices create a tense atmosphere but can also numb emotional impact.

Performances: strengths and uneven beats

Sam Claflin brings a low-burning intensity to Joel. He sells the character’s haunted state through small gestures and a steady presence. Bill Nighy provides gravitas as the patriarchal therapist, even when the script reduces him to cryptic exposition.

  • Alexandra Roach plays Joel’s sister with simmering confusion and distance.
  • Karla Crome appears as an ex-wife tangled in past wounds.
  • Supporting roles vary from restrained to exaggerated, and that range affects tone.

When acting matches the show’s restraint, scenes land. When direction pushes for theatricality, the effect can be jarring.

Writing, character work, and realism

The scripts favor plot momentum over natural dialogue. Characters frequently speak in full names or deliver lines meant to clarify rather than reveal authentic emotion. That emphasis on exposition can make people feel like plot devices.

As the season progresses, the series piles on mysteries and red herrings. This creates a puzzle-box rhythm. But it sometimes sacrifices deeper emotional insight into why people behave as they do.

Tone, violence, and narrative balance

The show oscillates between psychological drama and pulpy shocks. Stylized violence and sudden disclosures appear across episodes. Some viewers will find the risks compelling. Others may see them as prefabricated jolts meant to distract from character gaps.

What works and what falters

  • Works: strong lead performance, striking visuals, and a tense central hook.
  • Falters: heavy-handed scoring, inconsistent supporting turns, and occasional melodrama.
  • The series raises intriguing themes about inherited trauma and identity. The execution, however, can be uneven.

Standout creative contributors

  • Creators: Harlan Coben and Danny Brocklehurst
  • Lead cast: Sam Claflin, Bill Nighy, Alexandra Roach, Karla Crome
  • Setting: contemporary London, which acts as both backdrop and character

Viewer experience and unanswered threads

The show’s structure deliberately leaves questions open as it climbs toward a finale. Viewers who enjoy slow-burn puzzles will appreciate the layered reveals. Those who prefer tighter closure may be frustrated by the dangling elements.

Expect to be pulled between psychological mystery and thriller beats. The tone rarely sits still long enough to settle.

Release details and how to tune in

Harlan Coben’s Lazarus premieres October 22 on Prime Video. The six-episode run is available to stream on that platform.

Give your feedback

★★★★★

5.0/5 based on 1 rating
or leave a detailed review



Paris Joaillerie is an independent media. Support us by adding us to your Google News favorites:

Post a comment

Publish a comment★★★★★