Show summary Hide summary
- How the podcast began and when things changed
- Notaro’s reason for leaving: mixing comedy with politics
- Heckling and hostility during live performances
- How the partnership shifted after the exit
- Friendship frayed: Notaro on changing contact and feelings
- Addressing reports that she ‘dumped’ Hines
- Hines’ perspective on the fallout
When a beloved comedy duo split, fans assumed a creative rift. The real reason was louder: politics. Comedian Tig Notaro walked away from the podcast she co-hosted with Cheryl Hines as Hines’ husband, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., stepped onto the national stage. The move forced Notaro to choose between her art and the fallout from a high‑profile political campaign.
How the podcast began and when things changed
Tig and Cheryl: True Story launched in 2020 as a light, weekly deep dive into documentary films. The format was simple: two comedians riff and unpack what they watched.
Liam Payne’s final moments revealed by girlfriend Kate Cassidy on 2nd anniversary
Phoebe Bridgers voices Conor Oberst’s new short film Invention 13
- 2020 — Podcast debut, quickly built a casual, loyal audience.
- May 2023 — Tig Notaro exited the show.
- One month earlier — Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced a run tied to the 2024 election.
Notaro’s reason for leaving: mixing comedy with politics
Notaro has since explained she felt the growing political visibility made continuing untenable. What began as a private discomfort became public friction.
She said the association was distracting and changing the tone of her work. The attention directed at Hines’ husband started to affect the podcast and Notaro’s live shows.
Notaro’s concerns in her own words
- She worried that beliefs connected to Hines’ marriage were becoming more prominent.
- Notaro felt the podcast’s lighthearted tone clashed with the political momentum around Kennedy.
- She chose to step away rather than let those tensions shape her comedy.
Heckling and hostility during live performances
Notaro said crowds began reacting to her connection to Hines and Kennedy. Fans sometimes interrupted sets with political shouts.
She described instances of heckling that made performing uncomfortable. That pressure contributed to her decision to distance herself from the joint project.
How the partnership shifted after the exit
Hines initially understood Notaro’s choice and wanted to continue the podcast. Production later resumed with a new co-host, and then ended months after Notaro left.
- Rachael Harris stepped in as Notaro’s replacement.
- By December 2023, the podcast had stopped production.
Friendship frayed: Notaro on changing contact and feelings
After the professional split, Notaro says the personal relationship cooled. She continued reaching out but noticed Hines stopped initiating contact.
Notaro said she moved through denial to acceptance as she came to terms with the change in their dynamic.
Addressing reports that she ‘dumped’ Hines
Notaro pushed back on headlines that suggested she abandoned Hines. She insists she tried to remain a supportive friend even as she left the show.
Her message to the press was clear: stepping away from a public project is not the same as ending a friendship.
Hines’ perspective on the fallout
Hines has said she felt limited in how she could respond. She acknowledged that Notaro needed space and that there was little she could do but respect that choice.
The two women’s split illustrates how political spotlight can reshape personal and creative partnerships.
