Show summary Hide summary
- Shue and Fiebig confirm engagement amid recent headlines
- How the four became a tabloid story
- Timeline: key moments in the fallout and new beginnings
- Public comments from Holmes and Robach about the timeline
- Shue on personal growth, family and a new chapter
- What this means for their public images and projects
Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig have quietly announced they are engaged, a development that comes shortly after their former partners, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, were married. The news lands amid lingering public interest in the breakup that first made headlines when the four were linked in a scandal at ABC’s GMA3. Both Shue and Fiebig say the relationship grew from friendship as they recovered from their divorces.
Shue and Fiebig confirm engagement amid recent headlines
The couple made their engagement public this fall. Shue, 59, described the moment as one of gratitude and hope, telling reporters that the relationship arrived unexpectedly and brought a sense of peace. Fiebig is 49.
Jen Affleck teases next Bachelorette bid: reveals future on OG Mormon Wives
Love Is Blind star Michaella Giorgio speaks out about awkward onstage fall at reunion
The announcement follows closely on the heels of Robach and Holmes’ private wedding in Arkansas on September 19. Media outlets reported the marriage earlier this month.
How the four became a tabloid story
Interest in these intertwined relationships began in November 2022. At that time, images surfaced of Robach and Holmes together outside the workplace. Both were cohosts on GMA3 then. Each had been married to someone else when those pictures appeared.
- Robach was still legally married to Andrew Shue when the photos were published.
- Holmes was married to Marilee Fiebig at that same moment.
- Within weeks, all four faced intense media scrutiny and career fallout.
Timeline: key moments in the fallout and new beginnings
- November 2022 — Photos of Robach and Holmes together trigger public backlash.
- January 2023 — Reports say both hosts left ABC and were removed from GMA3.
- Throughout 2023 — Statements and interviews from everyone involved sought to clarify timing.
- December 2023 — Holmes and Robach discussed the chronology of their relationship on their podcast, saying divorce proceedings were already under way.
- September 19, 2024 — Robach and Holmes marry privately in Arkansas.
- One month later — Shue and Fiebig announce their engagement.
Public comments from Holmes and Robach about the timeline
Holmes has argued the public narrative mischaracterized their situation. He and Robach say they were in the process of separating from their spouses when the images went public. They have emphasized they were not secretly continuing marriages at that time.
Robach likewise told interviewers that legal and professional steps toward divorce were already in motion before her relationship with Holmes became public. Both said they believed they had the right to privacy while handling family matters.
Shue on personal growth, family and a new chapter
Shue has spoken about the difficulty of the breakup and what he learned from it. He framed the experience as one that prompted hard self-reflection. He said building a stable family and showing a loving home to his children became central to how he viewed the future.
Shue also described his relationship with Fiebig as evolving from friendship. He suggested the timing of their connection allowed both to open up while processing major life changes. He called the outcome a surprising, positive turn.
What this means for their public images and projects
All four continue to navigate public attention while pursuing different paths. Shue has mentioned involvement with a grassroots group called The Forum, and he has tied that work to broader hopes of helping communities. The recent personal news could shift how fans and media view each person’s next steps.
As their stories keep drawing coverage, commentators and followers are watching how private healing and public narratives intersect for everyone involved.
